Skip to content
Home » Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray review

Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray review

If you are searching high and low for a timeless neutral paint color, Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray might be the ideal fit for your needs. The gorgeous silvery gray tone makes a beautiful backdrop for all sorts of rooms.

It’s one of Benjamin Moore’s best-selling paint colors, and a favorite of both homeowners and interiors designers. Below, we’ll look at why it’s so popular, similar colors you can use, the colors that work well with Stonington Gray, and photos of the color in real homes.

What color is Stonington Gray HC-170?

The name gives some of it away, but Stonington Gray is a mid-tone gray with neutral undertones. It’s on the cooler side, and can look almost taupe in certain lights.

What is the LRV of Stonington Gray?

Stonington Gray has an LRV (or light reflective value) of 59.36, which makes it a medium gray.

If you’ve never heard of LRV, I’ll explain. It’s worth knowing because it makes paint colors so much easier to evaluate, especially if you’re choosing between two similar shades.

LRV measures the light reflectiveness of a paint color. It’s measured on a scale of 0-100, with 0 being the blackest of black paints, and 100 being a true white. Stonington Gray’s LRV of 59.36 makes it a medium tones gray. For comparison purposes, Benjamin Moore Simply White, one of the brands best white paint colors, has an LRV of 89.52 and is one of the company’s brightest shades. Generally, paint colors range between a two or three LRV, and a 93 LRV, since there isn’t a true white or true black paint color.

Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray properties

Although grays in general are a classic, they’ve taken the design world by storm over the last ten years. Muted gray tones are considered an excellent way to freshen up a room and introduce sophistication. Stonington Gray is one of Benjamin Moore’s best sellers.

The medium shade of gray is brings tranquility to a room. It’s considered a neutral gray that can read cooler in certain lights. But, it’s still solidly neutral, which is apparent when you hold it up next to true warm and cool grays, like the warm-toned Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray. It’s neutral-ness makes it a great fit for all sorts of spaces.

What undertones does Stonington Gray have?

Stonington Gray is a lovely medium gray tone with cool undertones, i.e. green, blue and purple. Under specific light conditions, the blue undertone will become prevalent. Therefore, consider this before you decide to commit to this color choice.

Certain lighting will make Stonington Gray’s cooler tones stand out, like overhead ambient light at night.

Below, we’re sharing examples of the color used in different rooms, plus complementary hues, and similar colors if you find that Stonington Gray isn’t quite right for you, or you’re looking for other options for your project before you make your final choice.

Where to use Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray

Stonington Gray Entryway

If you want to make the best first impression, Stonington Gray is excellent for your entryway. The paint color will help you create a curated foyer that wishes a warm welcome to your guests. Go for a carefully selected combination of muted grays to create a subtle but elegant space.

Stonington Gray Bedroom

When choosing the right paint color for your bedroom, serene and calm tones are your best choice. With its medium tone, Stonington Gray is the ideal choice for sprucing up your bedroom. Feel free to complement it with warm whites for a modern and cozy look. However, be sure to check how the warm and cool colors behave when placed next to each other. The blue tone in Stonington Gray might highlight the yellow tone in some warm whites. If this isn’t the look you’re going for, be sure to check how the color combination behaves under different lighting.

Make an accent wall stand out

An accent wall will make a remarkable statement and add a stylish note to your home. For this project, you might want to use bold colors that stand out. However, you would like to provide the perfect neutral backdrop to highlight its beauty. For example, a navy focal wall will perfectly stand out among gray walls.

Stonington Gray living room

A medium gray shade like Stonington Gray is the ideal choice for a living room. The cool neutrals set a subtle base, allowing you to play with the other elements. Therefore, you are free to add a pop of color and inject dynamics into the space. Yellow accents bring energy to your living room and lift the mood. For a feminine touch, you can add coral or pink details.

Stonington Gray bathroom

When remodeling your bathroom, choosing the right paint color can be overwhelming. If you are going for a simple and modern look, then Stonington Gray will ideally fit your requirements. The calm tone will complement marble to perfection, creating a sophisticated space that feels like a luxurious spa. Therefore, the medium gray color will flatter the marble tile flooring or a marble countertop.

Stonington Gray house exterior

If you plan to revamp the exterior, Stonington Gray is one of the options to consider as your final choice. The fresh color will enhance the curb appeal while subtly flattering your style. If you are looking for a natural look and mimic the exterior of a mountain house, feel free to use faux stone tiling. Opt for crisp white details if you want a modern and sleek look.use Chantilly Lace to paint the trims for a gorgeous contrast that makes a statement. For a stylish and sophisticated look, you can opt for darker gray. If your house receives plenty of sunlight, keep in mind that the color will look lighter.

What colors go with Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray

A crisp white trim and walls painted with Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray seem to be decorators’ favorite combination. The medium gray makes the bright white tones stand out, highlighting the beauty of the trim and its details.

Stonington Gray is a versatile color that can be used as a base to build your color scheme. If you are looking for colors that go with Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray, check Puritan Gray, Chantilly Lace, Lychee, and Decorator’s White. The gray matches perfectly with muted tones to create a subtle color palette that conveys peacefulness and tranquility.

Chantilly Lace

Chantilly Lace is a gorgeous crisp white tone that would make the perfect contrast with Stonington Gray. The classic white color is ideal for trims to complement the lovely gray tone.

Chantilly Lace has an LRV of 90.4, which means it’s a very bright white. The cool undertones of Stonington Gray will make Chantilly Lace read even more like a true, crisp white. It’s an ideal palette for contemporary interiors.


Stonington Gray works well with warm tones, so Lychee is one of the recommended matches. The creamy tone is the palest shade of peach will illuminate the space with its high LRV.

Decorator’s White

Decorator’s White is a bright white tone with a cool gray undertone, making the perfect match with Stonington Gray. Like Chantilly Lace, these colors are perfect if you are after a timeless, but modern color palette.

What paint is similar to Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray

If you are looking for paint similar to Stonington Gray, you would want to consider the following choices: Silver Chain, Sleigh Bells, Nimbus, and Arctic Gray.

Silver Chain

Silver Chain is a cool gray color that is an ideal replacement for Stonington Gray. The sophisticated tone is pretty similar but a little darker.

Sleigh Bells

Just like Stonington Gray, Sleigh Bells is a beautiful cool gray. It has a slightly higher LRV, meaning that it is a lighter tone.


Nimbus is somewhere between gray and beige but still manages to fit perfectly with both cool and warm tones. If you are looking for a somewhat flexible color but still want to keep gray’s neutral character, then this would be the ideal replacement for Stonington Gray.

Arctic Gray

Arctic Gray is the ideal replacement if you look for a color with an outstanding cool vibe. Being part of the classic collection, it will complement a wide range of cool neutrals.

What is the undertone of Stonington Gray?

Stonington Gray has a slight mild blue undertone. Also, it can have a slight purple undertone under specific light conditions. The gorgeous stone is a cold gray that will make a great contrast with crisp white colors. When paired with cool-toned whites, the blue tone tends to stand out. However, when you pair Stonington Gray with warm whites, things take a different direction. The blue undertone will bring out the yellow undertone in warm colors.

1 thought on “Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray review”

  1. Pingback: Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray – Inspiration DIY

Comments are closed.